AmericanDelicatessenMusic/Events/Other

Mustard Or Ketchup On A Hot Pastrami On Rye?

Posted on October 27th, 2025 · American Delicatessen Music/Events/Other

* Mustard Or Ketchup On A Hot Pastrami On Rye?

I already know “the answer”…

26 Comments to “Mustard Or Ketchup On A Hot Pastrami On Rye?”

  1. Leon Marcus says...

    Mustard hands down.

  2. Greg Sanders says...

    Mustard

  3. Nat Stein says...

    I love both. But if I had to pick just one Ketchup!

  4. Sheldon Davis says...

    I like mustard but love ketchup on my pastrami on rye.

  5. Ed Goren says...

    This one is a no brainer.

    Mustard.

  6. Fred Okun says...

    Mustard.

  7. Andy Gold says...

    It is sacreligous to put ketchup on a pastrami on rye.

  8. Peter Gordon says...

    Mustard

  9. Donna Turner says...

    Mustard.

  10. Barry Rothman says...

    Mustard.

  11. Marty Wechsler says...

    AI Overview
    Mustard is the traditional and recommended choice for pastrami, as its spicy, savory flavor complements the meat, while ketchup is generally not recommended because it can clash with the rich, salty taste of pastrami. The classic New York pastrami sandwich features spicy brown mustard on rye bread, often with a side of pickle.

  12. Jack Cohen says...

    To tell you the truth I like both. I know that most people go with mustard, but ketchup is reall good.

  13. PUT THIS 67 YEAR OLD DOWN FOR MUSTARD. When I was a kid I put ketchup on everything.

  14. IRA KATZMAN says...

    I put mustard on my pastrami. Kechup sounds disgusting.

  15. Tom Dean says...

    Mustard.

  16. Joshua Aaronson says...

    I love Ketchup on my Pastrami.

  17. Joe Kennedy says...

    Mustard.
    Ketchup, no way.

  18. Mark Castro says...

    Mustard.

  19. Judy Wein says...

    Ketchup, you must be kidding.

  20. Julie S says...

    Jeff, nothing beats a good pastrami on rye with spicy brown mustard.

  21. Georgia Carrera says...

    Mustard

  22. DONT HURT ME, i love ketchup on my pastrami sandwich.

  23. Rhonda Romano says...

    Call me a wild and crazy guy but I really enjoy a combo of mustard and and ketchup in my pastrami on rye.

  24. Ben Lefcourt says...

    Silly question, MUSTARD!

  25. Irving Singer says...

    Mustard.

  26. Ron Sklar says...

    mustard, of course!

Leave a Comment